e-ITT for the provision of Lymington Health and Leisure Roof Refurbishment

This tender presents significant data consistency issues regarding the submission deadline and lacks crucial evaluation criteria, severely impacting fairness and clarity. While basic information is present and e-submission is supported, restrictive eligibility criteria further limit competition.

The tender defines the procedure type and assigns a CPV code, and no disputes are noted. However, the absence of a clear reveal date is a minor transparency concern. The UK SME/VCSE requirement, while potentially aligned with national policy, could be seen as limiting broader market access.

The project description and AI-extracted requirements are clear and understandable. However, the complete absence of specified evaluation criteria is a major deficiency, making it difficult for bidders to understand how their proposals will be assessed.

Basic information, estimated value, and contract duration are provided, and relevant documents are attached. Nevertheless, the tender is incomplete due to the critical omission of evaluation criteria and the conflicting submission deadlines.

Fairness is significantly compromised by the absence of objective and transparent evaluation criteria. Furthermore, the mandatory eligibility requirements for UK SMEs and VCSEs, while potentially supporting local policy, restrict competition and could be perceived as tailoring the tender to a specific type of bidder.

The tender supports electronic submission via a specified portal and provides a clear contract start date and duration. While documents are listed, direct URLs for easy access are not explicitly provided in the summary, which is a minor inconvenience.

This category presents a critical flaw: the submission deadline stated in the 'Timeline' (2026-03-27) directly contradicts the date repeatedly mentioned in the 'Description' and 'Additional Info' (2026-02-27). This severe inconsistency can lead to confusion, missed deadlines, and potential legal challenges.

The tender includes a social aspect by targeting UK SMEs and VCSEs, which supports local and social enterprises. However, it lacks explicit mention of green procurement, innovation focus, or broader social criteria, indicating limited integration of sustainability principles.