Co-op Academy North Manchester - Replacement 3 G Pitches and associated works

This tender for 3G pitch renewal is clear in its scope but suffers from significant deficiencies in legal compliance, clarity, completeness, and fairness due to missing critical information such as evaluation criteria and detailed eligibility requirements.

The tender lacks detailed mandatory exclusion grounds, eligibility requirements, and crucially, evaluation criteria, which are fundamental for compliance with transparency principles, even for below-threshold procedures. Missing reveal date and procedure codes are minor issues.

While the description and scope of works are very clear, the absence of evaluation criteria makes it unclear how bids will be assessed. The lack of detailed eligibility and exclusion requirements also reduces overall clarity for potential bidders.

Basic information is mostly present, but the tender is incomplete due to the critical absence of evaluation criteria and detailed mandatory exclusion/eligibility requirements. The liable person and procedure codes are also missing.

The most significant fairness concern is the complete absence of evaluation criteria, which renders the procurement process opaque and potentially subjective. While e-submission is supported and value is disclosed, this critical omission severely undermines transparency and equal treatment.

Electronic submission via the MultiQuote platform is supported, and key dates (contract start, duration) are clearly specified. The estimated value is provided. A direct document URL is not explicitly stated but documents are available.

A significant inconsistency exists in the estimated value, with the basic information stating 180,000.00 EUR and a document summary mentioning £150,000. Minor inconsistencies include missing liable person and procedure codes.

The tender does not explicitly include any green procurement, social aspects, or innovation focus. It is also not indicated as EU funded, which typically implies higher sustainability standards.