Legal Compliance100/100
The tender notice states that the requirement is subject to Public Procurement Regulations, which is a positive indication of legal intent. However, the absence of detailed tender documents prevents a thorough assessment of compliance with specific legal requirements regarding content, structure, and procedural fairness.
•Absence of detailed tender documents for a full legal compliance review.
Clarity40/100
While basic information like title, reference, and organization is clear, the core requirements for 'On Water Clothing and Equipment' are entirely undefined in the public notice. Bidders are directed to an eProcurement system for details, which means the initial advertisement lacks clarity on the actual scope of work and evaluation methodology.
•Lack of specific technical requirements or product specifications in the public notice.
•Absence of disclosed evaluation criteria and methodology.
Completeness83/100
The tender notice is significantly incomplete as it does not include any actual tender documents, detailed specifications, or evaluation criteria. It primarily functions as an announcement directing potential bidders to an external eProcurement system for further information.
•No tender documents attached or available with the public notice.
•Missing detailed technical specifications for the 'On Water Clothing and Equipment'.
Fairness60/100
The open procedure is generally fair, but the complete lack of detailed requirements and evaluation criteria in the public notice creates an information asymmetry. This could potentially disadvantage new market entrants or bidders unfamiliar with the contracting authority's specific needs, implicitly favoring incumbent suppliers due to the vagueness.
•Lack of detailed requirements and evaluation criteria in the public notice, potentially disadvantaging new bidders.
•Vague eligibility and technical requirements could implicitly favor incumbent suppliers.
Practicality40/100
The use of an eProcurement system (Jaggaer) for submission is practical for streamlining the bidding process. However, the requirement for bidders to register on an external system to access core tender documents adds an initial barrier and extra step, potentially deterring some interested parties.
•Bidders must register on an external system to access core tender documents, potentially increasing initial effort.
•No direct access to tender documents without system registration.
Data Consistency100/100
There is a notable discrepancy between the 'Estimated Value' stated as 93,000,000.00 EUR and the 'total estimated value for this Framework Agreement' described as between £30,000,000 and £74,000,000 (GBP) over 5 years. This difference in currency and magnitude requires clarification.
•Discrepancy between the stated 'Estimated Value' in EUR and the 'total estimated value for this Framework Agreement' in GBP (£30M-£74M).
Sustainability0/100
The provided tender information does not include any specific mention of green procurement, social criteria, or innovation focus. This indicates a missed opportunity to integrate broader sustainability objectives into the procurement process.
•Absence of any sustainability, social, or innovation criteria.