WRA010 2025 26 Welsh Revenue Authority Regulatory Impact Assessment Contract

This tender demonstrates good foundational elements with clear requirements but is significantly hampered by critical omissions regarding evaluation criteria and a notable inconsistency in the estimated contract value.

The tender clearly defines the procedure type and CPV code, and there are no reported disputes or suspensions. Basic mandatory disclosures are met, ensuring a generally compliant process. However, the absence of a clear reveal date is a minor transparency gap.

The project description is clear, and the AI-extracted requirements are well-structured and understandable. However, the critical omission of specified evaluation criteria significantly hinders the overall clarity of how bids will be assessed.

Essential information such as title, reference, organization, deadlines, value, duration, and location are provided. Most required documents are listed and summarized. The major deficiency is the lack of defined evaluation criteria, which is crucial for a complete tender package.

The estimated value is disclosed, and the requirements appear generic, not tailored to a specific company. However, the absence of transparent evaluation criteria creates a significant risk of subjective assessment. The lack of e-submission also presents a barrier to equal access and ease of participation.

Key practical details like the contract start date and duration are clearly specified. The primary practical drawback is the absence of electronic submission, which is a standard expectation for modern procurement processes and simplifies participation.

While dates are logical and no disputes are reported, there is a critical inconsistency in the estimated value, stated as 60,000.00 EUR in the basic information and £50,000 in the Official PDF. This discrepancy is a serious data integrity issue.

The tender does not explicitly incorporate green, social, or innovation criteria. While common for smaller, specialized service contracts, this results in a low score for this specific category.