Legal Compliance100/100
The notice clearly states the legal framework (Procurement Act 2023, Competitive Flexible Procedure, Light Touch Regime) and mandatory exclusion grounds, indicating adherence to regulatory requirements for a preliminary stage.
Clarity40/100
The description of the service, prison type, location, and contract duration is clear. The indicative timetable is also well-presented. However, the deferral of specific details to future documentation reduces overall clarity at this stage.
Completeness83/100
As a 'planned procurement notice,' it is inherently incomplete, lacking any attached documents, detailed specifications, specific evaluation criteria, or precise financial/technical thresholds. This limits the ability of potential bidders to fully understand the scope.
•No documents attached
•Missing evaluation criteria
Fairness60/100
The requirement for PFI operational experience, while relevant to the asset, significantly narrows the market, potentially limiting competition. The Competitive Flexible Procedure with bidder engagement can, however, foster a more tailored and fair dialogue with qualified entities.
•Highly specific requirement for PFI operational experience may limit competition
Practicality40/100
The indicative timetable provides a practical roadmap for bidders. The inclusion of bidder engagement and dialogue sessions is a practical approach for a complex, high-value contract under the Light Touch Regime.
Data Consistency100/100
All information provided within the notice is consistent, particularly regarding the contract duration, estimated value, and prison characteristics.
Sustainability0/100
The notice does not explicitly mention any green, social, or innovation criteria, which are increasingly important for public procurement under modern frameworks like the Procurement Act 2023, especially for long-term, high-value contracts.
•Not green procurement
•No social criteria