C369/2025/2026 - Cadw Grounds Maintenance Services (NE & Ynys Mon)

This tender provides a clear service description and supports electronic submission, but its quality is significantly hampered by the critical absence of explicit evaluation criteria, impacting clarity, completeness, and fairness for potential bidders.

The tender defines the procedure type and CPV code correctly, and the 28-day submission period is reasonable. However, the 'Missing reveal date' and the lack of specific mandatory exclusion grounds detailed in the summary (though referenced in the ITT) represent minor compliance gaps in the provided information.

While the service description and AI-extracted requirements are clear and comprehensive, the critical absence of specified evaluation criteria significantly reduces the overall clarity for bidders, making it difficult to understand how proposals will be assessed.

Most essential information such as title, reference, organization, deadlines, value, duration, and location are provided, and documents are listed. However, the tender is incomplete due to the significant omission of defined evaluation criteria.

The tender discloses the estimated value, provides reasonable deadlines, and enables e-procurement for equal access. However, the lack of explicit evaluation criteria severely compromises transparency and objectivity, hindering fair competition.

The tender clearly supports electronic submission via the eTenderWales platform, provides a clear contract start date and duration, and includes financing information. This makes the submission process practical for bidders.

Key fields are largely populated, and dates are logical and consistent. Minor inconsistencies include an empty 'Liable Person' field, a missing code for 'Type: Open', and the 'Missing reveal date' flag.

The tender does not explicitly mention any green procurement aspects, social criteria, or an innovation focus. This indicates a lack of integration of sustainability principles into the procurement process.