Legal Compliance100/100
The tender notice explicitly states that mandatory exclusion grounds are not specified, which is a significant legal omission for public procurement, potentially allowing ineligible bidders to participate and failing to meet basic compliance standards.
•Absence of specified mandatory exclusion grounds.
Clarity40/100
The project scope, two-stage process, and contractor expectations are clearly articulated. The use of RIBA stages and JCT contract types provides a clear and understandable framework for the project delivery.
Completeness83/100
While the notice provides a good overview of the project and process, the absence of mandatory exclusion grounds and, crucially, evaluation criteria makes the tender incomplete. The actual tender documents (1A, 3A) are referenced but not provided for full assessment.
•Missing mandatory exclusion grounds.
•Missing evaluation criteria for both stages of the procurement.
Fairness60/100
The lack of mandatory exclusion grounds and evaluation criteria severely impacts the fairness and transparency of the process, as bidders cannot fully understand the rules for participation or how their submissions will be judged. This creates an uneven playing field.
•Absence of specified mandatory exclusion grounds.
•Lack of clear evaluation criteria for shortlisting and contract award.
Practicality40/100
The two-stage approach with a Pre-Construction Services Agreement (PCSA) is a practical and effective method for complex Design & Build projects, allowing for collaborative design development, risk mitigation, and cost finalization before committing to the main construction contract.
Data Consistency100/100
The information provided within the tender notice is consistent, with no conflicting details regarding the project, procurement process, or stated requirements.
Sustainability50/100
The tender explicitly includes 'Social Criteria' and requires a 'robust approach to social value delivery,' indicating a commitment to social sustainability. 'Innovation Focus' is also a positive characteristic. However, environmental aspects ('green procurement') are not explicitly highlighted in the provided text.