Legal Compliance75/100
The tender clearly identifies itself as a Preliminary Market Engagement, which explains the absence of a formal procedure type and mandatory exclusion grounds. The CPV code is reasonably assigned for an information-gathering exercise preceding design. The missing reveal date is a metadata issue, but for a PME, it doesn't indicate non-compliance.
•Missing reveal date
•Procedure type not formally defined (though clarified as PME)
Clarity80/100
The description of the STEP project, its challenges, and the specific technical characteristics required for the BESS are exceptionally clear and detailed. The AI-extracted requirements are comprehensive and well-structured, making the scope of expertise sought very understandable.
•No explicit criteria for evaluating market input, though this is less critical for a PME
Completeness70/100
Basic information like title, reference, organization, and deadlines are provided. All listed documents are available and summarized. Requirements are well-defined. However, the reveal date is missing, and the value is classified, which slightly impacts overall completeness.
•Missing reveal date
•Value classified
Fairness85/100
The PME utilizes an e-sourcing portal, ensuring broad access for submissions. The interest in "all battery chemistries" and the explicit goal to "address knowledge gaps" suggest an open and non-tailored approach, despite the highly specific technical requirements driven by the project's unique nature. The classified value is a minor detractor.
Practicality65/100
Electronic submission is clearly supported via the Delta eSourcing portal, and direct links are provided. The contract start date and duration are specified for the future project, which is helpful. However, the lack of disclosed estimated value and detailed financing information reduces overall practicality for potential future bidders.
•Value not disclosed (classified)
•No detailed financing information
Data Consistency90/100
Key dates are logical and consistent, with the PME preceding a future contract start date by several years, which is appropriate for a project of this scale. There are no disputes or suspensions. While some fields like "Liable Person" are empty and "Type/Procedure" are "None," this is largely consistent with its PME status. The automated check's "No e-submission" contradicts the explicit text, which states e-submission is supported.
•"Liable Person" field empty
•Automated check contradiction on e-submission (resolved by prioritizing text)
Sustainability50/100
The project itself, focusing on fusion power and large-scale battery storage, inherently contributes to green energy and innovation. The PME explicitly seeks to address knowledge gaps, demonstrating a strong innovation focus. However, the tender documentation does not explicitly include specific green procurement criteria or social aspects.
•No explicit green procurement or social criteria in the PME documentation