Legal Compliance100/100
The notice provides basic information required for a tender announcement. However, the absence of actual tender documents (e.g., ITT, contract terms, full instructions) means a comprehensive assessment of legal compliance with procurement regulations is impossible. The method for evaluating bids against the stated requirements is also missing.
•Missing full tender documentation (e.g., Invitation to Tender, contract terms, detailed instructions).
•Absence of explicit evaluation criteria for bids.
Clarity40/100
The description of the required service, objectives, scope of work, deliverables, and compliance standards is generally clear and well-defined within the notice. Provider requirements are also clearly stated.
Completeness83/100
The tender notice is severely incomplete as a standalone procurement package. It lacks essential documents that would typically accompany a tender, such as detailed instructions to bidders, full terms and conditions, pricing schedules, and crucially, evaluation criteria.
•No documents attached or available for bidders.
•Missing detailed evaluation criteria and methodology for assessing bids.
Fairness60/100
While the technical requirements seem reasonable for the service, the lack of evaluation criteria and full documentation could hinder fair competition. The requirement for 'on-site attendance as required by DBW' could potentially favor local providers, but it is not overly restrictive without further clarification.
•Absence of evaluation criteria makes it difficult to assess how bids will be fairly compared.
•'On-site attendance as required by DBW' could be a minor barrier for non-local or remote providers, depending on its frequency and necessity.
Practicality40/100
The scope of work, deliverables, and timing are practical and align well with the nature of iXBRL tagging services. The requirements for provider experience and use of HMRC-recognized software tools are also practical for ensuring a competent provider.
Data Consistency100/100
The information provided within the notice is consistent. The stated objectives align logically with the scope of work and expected deliverables.
Sustainability25/100
The tender notice does not include any explicit sustainability (environmental, social, or economic) criteria or considerations.
•No green procurement criteria.
•No social criteria.