Legal Compliance100/100
The tender specifies an Open procedure and mentions mandatory exclusion grounds, aligning with basic procurement principles. However, the absence of explicit details regarding these grounds in the provided extract is a minor concern for transparency.
•Lack of explicit detail on mandatory exclusion grounds in the provided extract.
Clarity40/100
The tender's description of the DVSA's role, the framework's purpose, and the types of testing required (emission, noise, tyre) is clear and easy to understand.
Completeness83/100
This is a significant weakness. The tender explicitly states 'No documents attached' and 'No document content available,' including the crucial 'technical specification' mentioned in the description. The absence of evaluation criteria is also a major omission, preventing suppliers from understanding how their bids will be assessed.
•No documents attached or content available
•Missing technical specification
Fairness60/100
The commitment to a 'closed framework with no limit to the number of suppliers' promotes broad participation and fairness. However, the lack of detailed evaluation criteria could introduce subjectivity into the selection process, potentially undermining fairness.
•Potential for subjective evaluation due to missing evaluation criteria.
Practicality40/100
The framework model is a practical approach for DVSA to manage ongoing testing requirements. The absence of framework-level costs for suppliers is also practical. However, the lack of essential documentation makes it impractical for suppliers to prepare informed and competitive submissions.
•Impractical for suppliers to prepare informed bids without full documentation.
Data Consistency100/100
The provided information is largely consistent, with the exception of the 'MANDATORY EXCLUSION GROUNDS' category being listed without explicit details in the extracted requirements, which is more a completeness issue than a contradiction.
Sustainability0/100
The tender does not indicate any focus on green procurement, social criteria, or innovation, which is a missed opportunity for modern public procurement.
•Absence of green procurement criteria
•Absence of social criteria