Welsh Government - 'When I am Ready’ scheme evaluation

This tender for the evaluation of the 'When I am Ready' scheme presents significant deficiencies in clarity, completeness, and fairness due to the absence of explicit evaluation criteria and detailed legal requirements, despite having clear basic information.

The tender defines the procedure type and CPV code correctly, and no disputes are reported. However, the AI-extracted requirements indicate a lack of specific mandatory exclusion and eligibility grounds, which are fundamental legal requirements. The missing tender reveal date is also a minor compliance gap.

While the tender's description is clear, the critical absence of specified evaluation criteria significantly hinders clarity. The AI-extracted technical and financial requirements are high-level and lack the detail necessary for comprehensive bid preparation.

Basic information such as title, organization, value, duration, and location are provided. However, the tender is incomplete due to the critical absence of evaluation criteria and the lack of explicit mandatory exclusion and eligibility grounds in the AI-extracted requirements.

The estimated value is disclosed, and requirements appear generic, not tailored. Electronic submission is indicated, promoting equal access. However, the critical absence of evaluation criteria severely compromises fairness and transparency, as bidders cannot objectively understand the basis for award.

Electronic submission is supported, and key dates like contract start and duration are clearly specified. While a direct document URL is not explicitly provided in the basic info, the mention of an e-tender portal suggests accessibility.

Most key fields are populated, and dates are logical and consistent. There are minor gaps such as the 'Liable Person' field and type/procedure codes. A contradiction exists between the AI-extracted requirement for e-submission and the automated check's flag of 'No e-submission'.

The tender shows a complete absence of any explicit green procurement, social aspects, or innovation focus. It is also not indicated as EU funded, which often correlates with higher sustainability standards.