Legal Compliance100/100
The tender lacks specific details on mandatory exclusion grounds, eligibility requirements, and financial requirements, which are fundamental components of a legally compliant procurement process. Without these, bidders cannot fully assess their compliance or the contracting authority's adherence to procurement law.
•No specific mandatory exclusion grounds detailed.
•No specific eligibility requirements detailed.
Clarity40/100
While the project description and technical capability requirements are clear in outlining the desired expertise and project goals (net-zero, Passivhaus, low embodied carbon), the overall clarity of the procurement process is severely hampered by the absence of full tender documents. Bidders cannot understand the full scope, terms, or submission format.
•No documents attached.
•No document content available.
Completeness83/100
The tender information provided is critically incomplete. The absence of any attached documents, detailed exclusion/eligibility/financial requirements, and crucially, evaluation criteria, means that potential bidders lack the essential information needed to prepare a compliant and competitive bid.
•No documents attached.
•No document content available.
Fairness60/100
The highly specialized technical requirements (net-zero, Passivhaus, low embodied carbon, quality design, place making, large-scale monitoring) are appropriate for the project's ambition. However, the complete lack of evaluation criteria and full tender documents creates a significant risk of unfairness, as bidders cannot understand how their proposals will be assessed. This opacity could also lead to perceptions of tailoring, even if unintended.
•Missing evaluation criteria.
•Potential for perceived tailoring due to highly specific technical requirements combined with lack of evaluation criteria and full tender documents.
Practicality40/100
The project's technical requirements are practical and well-defined for achieving its sustainability goals. However, the procurement process itself is highly impractical for bidders due to the absence of essential documentation, making it impossible to formulate a proper submission.
•Absence of essential tender documents makes practical bid preparation impossible.
Data Consistency100/100
The provided summary data is internally consistent. The description aligns with the technical requirements and the stated 'Innovation Focus'.
Sustainability25/100
The tender explicitly prioritizes sustainability, focusing on net-zero carbon in use, Passivhaus certification, and low embodied carbon. This is a significant strength and aligns with modern green procurement principles.