Legal Compliance50/100
The tender correctly identifies the procedure type and CPV code, with no reported disputes. However, the absence of a reveal date and, critically, the complete omission of evaluation criteria are major legal compliance issues, undermining transparency and fair competition.
•Missing reveal date
•No evaluation criteria specified
Clarity55/100
The description of services, RIBA stages, and AI-extracted requirements are generally clear and detailed. Nevertheless, the complete absence of evaluation criteria creates significant ambiguity for bidders regarding the assessment process, severely impacting overall clarity.
•No evaluation criteria specified
Completeness40/100
While basic information like title, organization, deadlines, and value are present, a substantial portion of the listed tender documents are inaccessible (error pages). This, combined with the missing evaluation criteria, indicates critical gaps in the tender's completeness.
•3 out of 7 listed documents are error pages (inaccessible)
•No evaluation criteria specified
Fairness30/100
The requirements do not appear tailored, but fairness is severely compromised by the inaccessible tender documents, the complete lack of transparent evaluation criteria, and the absence of e-submission, which collectively hinder equal access and competitive bidding.
•Incomplete document access (error pages)
•No evaluation criteria specified
Practicality40/100
Key dates and duration are specified, but the lack of electronic submission options and the inaccessibility of several listed tender documents present significant practical barriers for potential bidders to prepare and submit a compliant proposal.
•No e-submission
•Inaccessible tender documents
Data Consistency65/100
Most key fields are populated, and dates are logical. However, there is a notable discrepancy between the estimated value in EUR and the value stated in GBP in the Official PDF. Additionally, some administrative fields are left blank, indicating minor data quality issues.
•Estimated value discrepancy (EUR vs GBP in PDF)
•Liable Person field empty
Sustainability25/100
The tender does not explicitly incorporate any green procurement, social responsibility, or innovation-focused criteria. While public consultation is part of the service, it is not a sustainability criterion for the tenderer.
•Not green procurement
•No social criteria