Legal Compliance100/100
The tender explicitly references and adheres to Regulation 21 (Reserved Contracts) and Regulation 28 (Open Procedure) of The Public Contracts (Scotland) Regulations 2015, providing a clear legal basis for reserving the contract for 'Supported Businesses'. The definition of a 'Supported Business' is also clearly stated, aligning with the regulation.
Clarity60/100
The description of services is clear and comprehensive, covering various aspects of landscape maintenance and tree care. The eligibility criteria for 'Supported Businesses' are precisely defined. The reference to 'Landscape Architects tender drawings' for detailed areas is good, assuming these are readily accessible.
Completeness100/100
While the service scope and eligibility are clear, the provided information lacks explicit details on mandatory exclusion grounds, comprehensive evaluation criteria for the award phase, and specific financial requirements (e.g., minimum turnover). Information on how to access the 'Landscape Architects tender drawings' is also not detailed.
•Missing detailed evaluation criteria for the award phase.
•Absence of explicit financial requirements (e.g., minimum turnover) in the provided extract.
Fairness80/100
The reservation for 'Supported Businesses' is a legally permissible and socially driven policy choice, not an indication of tailoring for a specific company. However, the absence of detailed evaluation criteria could introduce subjectivity into the assessment process, potentially affecting fairness among eligible bidders.
Practicality60/100
The scope of services is practical and typical for landscape maintenance, including specialized tree care. The 24-month contract duration is reasonable for service continuity. The 'Supported Business' requirement, while limiting the bidder pool, is an intended outcome of the social policy.
Data Consistency100/100
All provided information, including basic details, description, and document summaries, is consistent regarding the contract's nature, organization, and the 'Supported Business' reservation. CPV and NUTS codes align with the service and location.
Sustainability0/100
The tender strongly emphasizes social sustainability by reserving the contract for 'Supported Businesses', promoting the integration of disabled or disadvantaged persons. However, explicit environmental sustainability criteria are not mentioned in the provided extract.