Legal Compliance100/100
The tender mentions compliance with UK legal and regulatory frameworks, specifically CDM Regulations 2015. However, the lack of specified mandatory exclusion grounds is a significant legal omission. The absence of full tender documents makes a complete legal compliance check impossible.
•Missing mandatory exclusion grounds.
•Absence of full tender documentation prevents comprehensive legal compliance assessment.
Clarity40/100
The project description and technical requirements are generally clear and detailed, outlining the scope of work and the architect's responsibilities as Lead Consultant. However, the financial requirements regarding the inclusion of sub-consultant fees and survey costs introduce ambiguity regarding risk allocation.
•Ambiguity regarding the full extent of 'additional surveys' and the associated financial risk for bidders.
Completeness83/100
The tender is severely incomplete due to the complete absence of attached documents and, critically, the lack of evaluation criteria. While the project description and requirements are detailed, the fundamental elements required for bidders to prepare a compliant and competitive offer are missing.
•No tender documents attached.
•Missing evaluation criteria.
Fairness60/100
The absence of evaluation criteria makes it impossible for bidders to understand how their proposals will be assessed, severely impacting fairness and transparency. The requirement for the lead architect to directly appoint and include all sub-consultant and survey costs transfers significant financial risk to the bidder, potentially disadvantaging smaller firms or those less able to absorb such risks. The highly specific technical requirements, while relevant, could also limit competition.
•Absence of evaluation criteria compromises transparency and fairness.
•Significant financial risk transferred to the lead consultant by requiring inclusion of all sub-consultant and survey costs, potentially limiting competition.
Practicality40/100
The project scope and the Lead Consultant's role are practical and well-defined in terms of responsibilities (Turnkey, RIBA stages, Principal Designer). However, the requirement to include costs for potentially unknown 'additional surveys' upfront presents a practical challenge for accurate bidding. The lack of full documentation also creates practical hurdles for bidders.
•Requirement to include costs for unspecified 'additional surveys' upfront poses a practical challenge for accurate and competitive bidding.
•Lack of full tender documents makes it practically difficult for bidders to prepare comprehensive proposals.
Data Consistency100/100
The provided information appears consistent within itself, with the description aligning with the extracted requirements.
Sustainability0/100
The tender description mentions upgrading M&E systems for 'modern standards for energy efficiency,' which is a positive aspect related to environmental sustainability. However, there are no explicit green procurement, social, or innovation criteria specified.
•Lack of explicit social or innovation criteria.
•Limited focus on broader sustainability aspects beyond energy efficiency.