Legal Compliance55/100
The tender lacks a defined procedure type and code, which is a fundamental omission for legal compliance, even for an Expression of Interest. The requirement for a supplier to be located within the region could also be legally challenged if not adequately justified.
•Missing defined procedure type and code
•Potentially restrictive regional supplier requirement
Clarity70/100
The description of the required service and technical specifications for the vehicles is clear and well-detailed. However, the absence of specified evaluation criteria for the subsequent tender significantly reduces clarity for potential bidders.
•No evaluation criteria specified
•"Divided into Parts" characteristic mentioned without detail
Completeness60/100
While basic information like title, value, and duration are present, critical fields such as the procurement procedure type, liable person, and especially evaluation criteria are missing. The mention of 'Divided into Parts' without further detail also indicates incompleteness.
•Missing procurement procedure type and code
•Missing evaluation criteria
Fairness40/100
The requirement for suppliers to be located within the South Yorkshire region is highly restrictive and raises significant concerns about limiting competition and potential market tailoring. The absence of evaluation criteria also compromises transparency and objectivity, while the lack of e-submission limits equal access.
•Restrictive regional supplier requirement
•No evaluation criteria specified
Practicality60/100
The lack of electronic submission capability is a significant practical drawback in modern procurement, potentially increasing administrative burden for bidders. While contract dates and duration are clear, the absence of e-submission impacts overall practicality.
•No e-submission capability
Data Consistency80/100
Most key fields are populated, and dates are logical and consistent. The issues are primarily omissions (e.g., procedure type, liable person) rather than conflicting data, indicating good internal consistency for the data provided.
•Missing 'Type' and 'Procedure' fields
•Missing 'Liable Person' field
Sustainability70/100
The tender explicitly requires compliance with the End of Life Vehicle Regulations (2000/53/EC), which is a strong positive for environmental sustainability. However, there are no explicit social or innovation criteria mentioned.
•No explicit social criteria
•No explicit innovation focus