Legal Compliance75/100
The notice clearly states it is for market engagement, not a formal procurement, which means full legal compliance for a tender is not yet applicable. The CPV code is appropriate, and there are no disputes. The lack of a formal procedure type is consistent with its pre-procurement status.
•Missing reveal date (minor data point)
Clarity80/100
The description, objectives, and functional/technical requirements are clearly articulated and easy to understand for the purpose of market engagement. The AI-extracted requirements accurately reflect the content.
Completeness70/100
All basic information (title, reference, organization, description, deadlines, duration, CPV, NUTS) is provided. Requirements are well-defined. The estimated value is classified, which is acceptable for market engagement.
•Value not disclosed (acceptable for market engagement)
•Missing evaluation criteria (expected for market engagement)
Fairness55/100
While document access is full, the requirement for solutions to be "widely adopted within the UK Higher Education sector" and have "proven implementation and strong adoption within the higher education sector" is highly restrictive. This could significantly limit competition to a few established providers, potentially tailoring the future procurement to specific companies already dominant in that niche.
•Requirements potentially tailored to specific companies/market leaders within the UK HE sector
•No e-submission (minor for market engagement, but a general fairness concern for accessibility)
Practicality65/100
The contract start date and duration are clear. However, the lack of e-submission support could be a practical barrier for some interested parties. The undisclosed value also makes it harder for potential suppliers to assess the scale of the opportunity.
•No e-submission
•Value not disclosed
Data Consistency90/100
The information provided is largely consistent and logical across all sections and documents. Dates are logical, and there are no reported disputes or suspensions. The 'Type: None' and 'Procedure: None' are consistent with the notice's stated purpose.
•Liable Person field is empty
Sustainability20/100
The notice does not include any specific criteria or considerations related to green procurement, social aspects, or innovation.
•Not green procurement
•No social criteria