Removal of Abandoned Boats and Trailer Heswall Foreshore

This tender for abandoned boat removal is generally well-structured with clear project scope and basic information, but significantly lacks explicit evaluation criteria, which impacts fairness and clarity for potential bidders.

The tender defines the procedure type and CPV codes appropriately, and there are no reported disputes. However, the reveal date is missing, and specific mandatory exclusion grounds are not explicitly detailed, which are minor compliance gaps.

The project description and AI-extracted requirements are clear and understandable regarding the scope of work and environmental sensitivities. However, the critical absence of specified evaluation criteria significantly reduces overall clarity for bidders on how their proposals will be assessed.

The tender provides essential information such as title, organization, reference, estimated value, duration, and attached documents. A significant omission is the lack of defined evaluation criteria, which is crucial for a complete tender package.

Full document access, disclosed value, and e-procurement support contribute positively to fairness. However, the absence of objective and transparent evaluation criteria is a major concern, as it introduces subjectivity into the selection process and hinders equal opportunity for bidders.

Electronic submission is supported, and key dates like contract start and duration are provided. While documents are available, the lack of evaluation criteria makes it practically challenging for bidders to prepare targeted and competitive proposals.

The tender exhibits good data consistency with logical dates and no reported disputes. Minor inconsistencies include missing codes for procedure type and an empty 'Liable Person' field.

The project inherently addresses environmental protection due to its location in a legally protected SSSI RAMSAR site, requiring a methodology to prevent damage. However, it does not explicitly incorporate broader green, social, or innovation procurement criteria beyond this direct requirement.