Legal Compliance75/100
The PME clearly defines its non-formal procurement status and adheres to principles of fair market engagement. CPV codes are appropriate, and the submission deadline is reasonable for a PME. The 'Type: None' and 'Procedure: None' are acceptable given it's not a formal tender.
Clarity80/100
The description of the service and the purpose of the PME are clear and unambiguous. Requirements for PME participation are well-documented and understandable. The absence of evaluation criteria is appropriate for this pre-procurement stage.
Completeness70/100
All essential information for a Prior Market Engagement, such as title, organization, reference, estimated value, duration, and PME submission details, is provided. Documents are available, and location information is specified.
•Formal tender procedure type and specific evaluation criteria are not defined, which is expected for a PME but would be a concern for a full tender.
•One attached document (Planning Notice) appears to be from a different council (Cambridgeshire), which could indicate an irrelevant inclusion or data entry error.
Fairness85/100
The PME explicitly states that participation will not create an advantage in future procurement, promoting fairness. Document access is provided via an e-tendering system, the value is disclosed, and requirements are generic. The deadline for PME submission is reasonable.
Practicality80/100
Electronic submission is clearly supported via the specified e-tendering system, with a direct URL and contact information for technical support. The contract start date and duration are known, enhancing planning for potential future bidders.
Data Consistency90/100
Key fields are consistently populated, and dates are logical and coherent. There are no reported disputes or suspensions, indicating a stable project status. The only minor inconsistency is the inclusion of a document from a different council.
•One attached document (Planning Notice) is from a different council (Cambridgeshire), which is inconsistent with the main tender organization (Walsall Council).
Sustainability50/100
While the service itself addresses a significant social need, the PME documentation does not explicitly include green procurement, broader social criteria for suppliers, or innovation focus within the procurement process itself.
•No explicit green procurement criteria.
•No explicit social criteria for suppliers beyond the service's inherent social benefit.