UKRI-5440 - Systèmes de contrôle pour la recherche sur l'informatique quantique supraconductrice

This tender presents a clear technical objective for advanced quantum computing research but suffers from significant deficiencies in transparency, accessibility, and completeness of procedural information, notably lacking evaluation criteria and e-submission options.

The tender defines the procedure type and CPV code correctly, and no disputes are reported. However, the absence of a reveal date, explicit mandatory exclusion grounds, and crucially, specified evaluation criteria, raises significant legal compliance concerns for an open procedure.

The technical description and requirements for the superconducting qubit control system are clear and unambiguous. However, the overall clarity for bidders is severely hampered by the explicit absence of evaluation criteria, eligibility requirements, and financial requirements.

Basic information such as title, organization, value, and duration are provided. However, the tender is incomplete due to the stated absence of eligibility requirements, financial requirements, and evaluation criteria, which are fundamental components of a comprehensive tender package. Some codes and the liable person are also missing.

Fairness is significantly compromised by the lack of specified evaluation criteria, which are essential for transparent and objective assessment. The absence of e-submission and document URLs creates barriers to equal access. The requirement for 'technical compatibility' for future upgrades, while understandable for research, could potentially limit competition to a specific vendor's ecosystem.

Practicality is notably low for a tender in 2026. The lack of electronic submission capabilities and the absence of direct URLs for tender documents create significant logistical hurdles for potential bidders, hindering efficient participation. The contract start date and duration are clearly specified.

Most key fields are populated, and dates are logical. However, there are minor inconsistencies such as missing codes for the procedure type and liable person, a missing reveal date, and a discrepancy in the estimated value (EUR vs. GBP in document summaries).

The tender inherently focuses on innovation through its advanced quantum computing research objective. However, it completely lacks explicit criteria for green procurement or social aspects, which are increasingly important considerations in modern public procurement.